Judicial Corporal Punishment
What is your gender?
| 66% (99) | Male | |
|---|---|---|
| 34% (51) | Female | |
| 0% (0) | Other |
150 voters have answered this question.
What is your age?
| 4% (6) | Below 13 | |
|---|---|---|
| 20% (30) | 13-18 | |
| 10% (15) | 18-25 | |
| 22% (33) | 26-35 | |
| 12% (19) | 36-44 | |
| 14% (21) | 45-59 | |
| 17% (26) | 60+ |
150 voters have answered this question.
And where are you from?
| 43% (65) | Western or Central Europe | |
|---|---|---|
| 5% (8) | Eastern Europe | |
| 40% (60) | North America | |
| 1% (2) | South America | |
| 2% (3) | Middle East | |
| 1% (2) | Far East | |
| 0% (1) | Africa | |
| 2% (4) | Australia | |
| 3% (5) | Other |
150 voters have answered this question.
Do you think that judicial corporal punishment (JCP) should be reintroduced in modern legal system?
| 94% (141) | Yes. | |
|---|---|---|
| 6% (9) | No. |
150 voters have answered this question.
Which of the offences listed below should result in JCP?
| 83% (125) | Minor and non-violent offences (eg. vandalism, destruction of property, disturbance of public order). | |
|---|---|---|
| 73% (110) | Violent minor offences (eg. street fight without causing injury). | |
| 46% (70) | Traffic offences (eg. speeding). | |
| 72% (109) | Petty crimes (eg. pilfering, pickpocketing). | |
| 56% (85) | Serious but non-violent crimes (eg. theft, embezzlement, fraud). | |
| 44% (67) | Violent serious crimes (eg. rape, murder). | |
| 3% (5) | There should be no JCP at all. |
150 voters have answered this question.
What social groups, in your opinion, could be convicted to JCP.
| 57% (87) | Adult males. | |
|---|---|---|
| 74% (112) | Juvenile males. | |
| 67% (101) | Adult females. | |
| 76% (114) | Juvenile females. | |
| 3% (5) | No one should be convicted to JCP. |
150 voters have answered this question.
What should be the minimum age to order a JCP for juvenile offender?
| 4% (6) | 17 | |
|---|---|---|
| 10% (16) | 16 | |
| 3% (5) | 15 | |
| 10% (15) | 14 | |
| 10% (15) | 13 | |
| 15% (23) | 12 | |
| 4% (6) | 11 | |
| 16% (25) | 10 | |
| 0% (0) | 9 | |
| 6% (10) | 8 | |
| 2% (3) | 7 | |
| 12% (18) | 6 and less | |
| 5% (8) | I think juvenile offenders should not be sentenced to JCP. |
150 voters have answered this question.
Where the JCP should be administred?
| 12% (18) | In prisons only (even if the offender is not convicted to prison time he/she must go to prison only to be punished and is released immediately after execution). | |
|---|---|---|
| 33% (50) | In prisons, but not only. | |
| 42% (63) | In courts (rooms created specially for this). | |
| 34% (51) | In police stations (rooms created specially for this). | |
| 60% (91) | In special institution (corporal punishment centres). | |
| 12% (18) | Other places, please describe them... | |
| 3% (5) | Nowhere, there should be no JCP at all. |
150 voters have answered this question.
What do you think about public administration of JCP?
| 16% (25) | There should be no public JCP at all. | |
|---|---|---|
| 16% (25) | Public JCP should be reserved for serious offences. | |
| 16% (25) | Public JCP should be reserved for recidivists. | |
| 37% (56) | Public JCP could be ordered in any (even minor) case if the judge will find it appropriate. | |
| 28% (42) | All JCP should be administered in public. | |
| 13% (20) | It could be reserved for adult offenders only. | |
| 13% (20) | It could be reserved for juvenile offenders only. | |
| 4% (7) | There should be no JCP at all. |
150 voters have answered this question.
What form of JCP could be used on adult offenders?
| 34% (51) | Bare back whipping. | |
|---|---|---|
| 4% (7) | Clothed back whipping. | |
| 76% (115) | Bare buttocks lashing. | |
| 8% (13) | Clothed buttocks lashing. | |
| 15% (23) | Other forms of JCP. | |
| 13% (20) | There should be no JCP of adult offenders. |
150 voters have answered this question.
What implements could be used on adult offenders?
| 62% (93) | Cane. | |
|---|---|---|
| 46% (69) | Birch. | |
| 52% (78) | Strap. | |
| 24% (37) | Tawse. | |
| 41% (62) | Paddle. | |
| 34% (52) | Single tail whip. | |
| 28% (43) | Cat o' nine tails. | |
| 6% (9) | Other. | |
| 14% (21) | There should be no JCP of adult offenders. |
150 voters have answered this question.
How an adult offender should present for JCP?
| 4% (7) | Fully clothed. | |
|---|---|---|
| 24% (36) | Naked from the waist down. | |
| 2% (3) | Naked from the waist up. | |
| 4% (7) | Only genitals covered. | |
| 50% (75) | Completely nude. | |
| 0% (1) | Other. | |
| 14% (21) | There should be no JCP of adult offenders. |
150 voters have answered this question.
What form of JCP could be used on juvenile offenders?
| 26% (39) | Bare back whipping. | |
|---|---|---|
| 5% (8) | Clothed back whipping. | |
| 81% (122) | Bare buttocks lashing. | |
| 12% (19) | Clothed buttocks lashing. | |
| 13% (20) | Other forms of JCP. | |
| 6% (9) | There should be no JCP of juvenile offenders. |
150 voters have answered this question.
What implements could be used on juvenile offenders?
| 59% (89) | Cane. | |
|---|---|---|
| 43% (65) | Birch. | |
| 60% (90) | Strap. | |
| 28% (42) | Tawse. | |
| 52% (79) | Paddle. | |
| 26% (39) | Single tail whip. | |
| 18% (28) | Cat o' nine tails. | |
| 8% (12) | Other. | |
| 6% (9) | There should be no JCP of juvenile offenders. |
150 voters have answered this question.
How an juvenile offender should present for JCP?
| 3% (5) | Fully clothed. | |
|---|---|---|
| 31% (47) | Naked from the waist down (buttocks lashing). | |
| 2% (3) | Naked from the waist up (back whipping). | |
| 8% (12) | Only genitals covered. | |
| 47% (71) | Completely nude. | |
| 2% (3) | Other. | |
| 6% (9) | There should be no JCP of juvenile offenders. |
150 voters have answered this question.
What do you think about voluntary submission to JCP in some cases?
| 50% (76) | Offenders of all ages should have an option to voluntarily submit to JCP instead of fines or imprisonment. | |
|---|---|---|
| 5% (8) | Adult offenders should have an option to voluntarily submit to JCP instead of fines or imprisonment. | |
| 16% (24) | Juvenile offenders should have an option to voluntarily submit to JCP instead of fines or imprisonment. | |
| 24% (37) | No one should have an option to voluntarily submit to JCP instead of fines or imprisonment. | |
| 3% (5) | There should be no JCP at all. |
150 voters have answered this question.
Case #1: A 44 years old woman was found guilty of driving under the influence of alcohol. Which of the following is the most appropriate punishment?
| 8% (13) | Imprisonment for 6 months only. | |
|---|---|---|
| 14% (21) | Imprisonment for 3 months only. | |
| 6% (10) | Imprisonment for 3 months + 20 strokes on naked buttocks. | |
| 18% (28) | Imprisonment for 4 weeks + 50 strokes on naked buttocks. | |
| 4% (6) | Imprisonment for 4 weeks + 20 strokes on naked buttocks. | |
| 22% (33) | 50 strokes on naked buttocks only. | |
| 12% (19) | 20 strokes on naked buttocks only. | |
| 13% (20) | Other form of punishment. |
150 voters have answered this question.
Case #2: A 26 years old man was found guilty of shoplifting (stole a smartphone). Which of the following is the most appropriate punishment?
| 10% (16) | Imprisonment for 6 months only. | |
|---|---|---|
| 14% (22) | Imprisonment for 3 months only. | |
| 7% (11) | Imprisonment for 3 months + 20 strokes on naked buttocks. | |
| 17% (26) | Imprisonment for 4 weeks + 50 strokes on naked buttocks. | |
| 8% (12) | Imprisonment for 4 weeks + 20 strokes on naked buttocks. | |
| 14% (22) | 50 strokes on naked buttocks only. | |
| 16% (24) | 20 strokes on naked buttocks only. | |
| 11% (17) | Other form of punishment. |
150 voters have answered this question.
Case #3: A 16 years old girl was found guilty of underage drinking of alcohol and disturbance of peace. Which of the following is the most appropriate punishment?
| 10% (15) | 30 hours of community work only. | |
|---|---|---|
| 8% (13) | 20 hours of community work only. | |
| 14% (21) | 30 hours of community work + 20 strokes on naked buttocks. | |
| 28% (42) | 20 hours of community work + 30 strokes on naked buttocks. | |
| 13% (20) | 30 strokes on naked buttocks only. | |
| 14% (22) | 20 strokes on naked buttocks only. | |
| 11% (17) | Other form of punishment. |
150 voters have answered this question.
Case #4: A 15 years old boy was found guilty of destruction of property (damaged the bus stop). Which of the following is the most appropriate punishment?
| 8% (13) | 30 hours of community work only. | |
|---|---|---|
| 9% (14) | 20 hours of community work only. | |
| 12% (18) | 30 hours of community work + 20 strokes on naked buttocks. | |
| 26% (40) | 20 hours of community work + 30 strokes on naked buttocks. | |
| 16% (24) | 30 strokes on naked buttocks only. | |
| 15% (23) | 20 strokes on naked buttocks only. | |
| 12% (18) | Other form of punishment. |
150 voters have answered this question.
Thank you very much for participating. Feel freely to leave a comment.
| 26% (40) | I'll leave a comment. | |
|---|---|---|
| 73% (110) | I don't want to leave any comments. |
150 voters have answered this question.
