Would you spank her?
Say you had a preteen daughter (roughly 9 or 10 years old) She knows that she will be severely spanked if she is bad. She is actually a very good girl she is just clumsy and forgetful. Would you spank her to discipline these traits out of her.
What is your age and sex?
| 9% (54) | Male under 18. | |
|---|---|---|
| 27% (151) | Male 18-40. | |
| 19% (108) | Male 41+ | |
| 11% (65) | Female under 18. | |
| 27% (153) | Female 18-40. | |
| 3% (21) | Female 41+ |
552 voters have answered this question.
Males. She is playing. You tell her to be careful not to break anything. She accidently smashes an ornament. "I'm sorry I didn't mean too." she pouts. What do you do?
| 3% (12) | Under 18 Boys. She apologized. You just tell her to be more careful in future. | |
|---|---|---|
| 6% (22) | Under 18 Boys. Grab her, tell her off, give her bottom a few hard swats to emphasize the point then tell her to clean up the mess. | |
| 7% (26) | Under 18 Boys. Pull the clumsy girl over your knee and teach her a proper lesson. A sore bottom will remind her to be more careful in future. | |
| 14% (47) | Over 18 men. She apologized. Just tell her to be more careful in future. | |
| 20% (69) | Over 18 men. Grab her, tell her off, give her bottom a few hard swats to emphasize the point then tell her to clean up the mess. | |
| 46% (156) | Over 18 men. Pull the clumsy girl over your knee and teach her a proper lesson. A sore bottom will remind her to be more careful in future. |
332 voters have answered this question.
Females. She is playing. You tell her to be careful not to break anything. She accidently smashes an ornament. "Sorry I didn't mean too." she pouts. What do you do?
| 7% (22) | Under 18 girls. She apologized. You tell her to be more careful in future. | |
|---|---|---|
| 9% (28) | Under 18 girls. Grab her, tell her off, give her bottom a few hard swats to emphasize the point then tell her to clean up the mess. | |
| 15% (43) | Under 18 girls. Pull the clumsy girl over your knee and teach her a proper lesson. A sore bottom will remind her to be more careful in future. | |
| 6% (19) | Over 18 women. She apologized. Just tell her to be more careful in future. | |
| 19% (56) | Over 18 women. Grab her, tell her off, give her bottom a few hard swats to emphasize the point then tell her to clean up the mess. | |
| 40% (116) | Over 18 women. Pull the clumsy girl over your knee and teach her a proper lesson. A sore bottom will remind her to be more careful in future. |
284 voters have answered this question.
Males. You catch her doing something dangerous that you told her never to do because she could get seriously hurt. "Er....Sorry I forgot. I wont do it again I promise" she says.
| 0% (2) | Under 18 Boys. She apologized. Just tell her don't ever do it again. | |
|---|---|---|
| 4% (14) | Under 18 Boys. Grab her, sternly tell her off explaining why it is dangerous and give her bottom a few very hard swats to emphasize the point so she understands. | |
| 14% (47) | Under 18 boys. Pull the clumsy forgetful girl over your knee, scold her, then pull her panties down and teach her a proper lesson that she will never forget. Having a very sore and painful bottom will do her a lot more good than if she ends up in hospital. | |
| 3% (10) | Over 18 men. She apologized. Just tell her don't ever do it again. | |
| 9% (32) | Over 18 men. Grab her, sternly tell her off explaining why it is dangerous and give her bottom a few very hard swats to emphasize the point so she understands. | |
| 67% (223) | Over 18 men. Pull the clumsy forgetful girl over your knee, scold her, then pull her panties down and teach her a proper lesson that she will never forget. Having a very sore and painful bottom will do her a lot more good than if she ends up in hospital. |
328 voters have answered this question.
Females. You catch her doing something dangerous that you told her never to do because she could get seriously hurt. "Er....Sorry I forgot. I wont do it again I promise" she says.
| 0% (1) | Under 18 girls. She apologized. Just tell her don't ever do it again. | |
|---|---|---|
| 5% (16) | Under 18 girls. Grab her, sternly tell her off explaining why it is dangerous and give her bottom a few very hard swats to emphasize the point so she understands. | |
| 27% (76) | Under 18 girls. Pull the clumsy forgetful girl over your knee, scold her, then pull her panties down and teach her a proper lesson that she will never forget. Having a very sore and painful bottom will do her a lot more good than if she ends up in hospital. | |
| 0% (1) | Over 18 women. She apologized. Just tell her don't ever do it again. | |
| 6% (18) | Over 18 women. Grab her, sternly tell her off explaining why it is dangerous and give her bottom a few very hard swats to emphasize the point so she understands. | |
| 60% (169) | Over 18 women. Pull the clumsy forgetful girl over your knee, scold her, then pull her panties down and teach her a proper lesson that she will never forget. Having a very sore and painful bottom will do her a lot more good than if she ends up in hospital. |
281 voters have answered this question.
Should this girl be spanked?
| 6% (34) | No. She is not a bad girl. | |
|---|---|---|
| 93% (518) | Yes it is for her own good. |
552 voters have answered this question.
How sore should her bottom be.
| 4% (27) | She should not be spanked. | |
|---|---|---|
| 11% (63) | Not very. Pink. | |
| 40% (224) | Red. | |
| 43% (238) | Dark red and very sore. |
552 voters have answered this question.
Would you be more likely to spank a preteen boy instead of a girl?
| 6% (38) | Yes I would spank the boy a lot more than the girl. | |
|---|---|---|
| 37% (209) | I would spank the boy less, girls need to be spanked more. | |
| 5% (32) | I would not spank a boy or girl in either of the above scenarios. | |
| 49% (273) | I would spank both hard. |
552 voters have answered this question.
Which of these philosophies is best for raising a daughter?
| 21% (119) | 1)Only spank her for serious offences but when you do spank her it must be very hard so she knows that she has been a bad girl and will be severely punished. | |
|---|---|---|
| 40% (226) | 2)She should be spanked regularly and very often but the intensity of her spankings should be proportional to the severity of her offence. | |
| 37% (207) | 3)She should be spanked very severely every single time she does something wrong and if she does not cry then it is not a proper spanking. |
552 voters have answered this question.
Justify your choice.
| 19% (109) | I voted for 1) because if you spank her too often the spanking loses its effect. | |
|---|---|---|
| 38% (213) | I voted for 2) because suddenly threatening severe spankings could shock/traumatize her. This way she learns how severity of punishment fits the crime and she will be more likely to accept a severe spanking when she is bad. | |
| 41% (230) | I voted for 3) to make sure she is disciplined, otherwise she will push the envelope to see what she can get away with. |
552 voters have answered this question.
This poll was created on 2014-02-21 21:30:13
by Dazo
