American Idol All-Stars
Looking for the old results?
If American Idol were to have an All-Star season, who would be in it? Vote for who you think is deserving of a spot, whether or not it's because they were among the best singers or because they had the most dynamic personalities.
Which of the following contestants from SEASON 1 would you put into All-Stars?
| 100% (5) | Kelly Clarkson | |
|---|---|---|
| 40% (2) | Justin Guarini | |
| 0% (0) | Nikki McKibbin | |
| 40% (2) | Tamyra Gray | |
| 0% (0) | R.J. Helton | |
| 0% (0) | Christina Christian | |
| 0% (0) | Ryan Starr | |
| 0% (0) | A.J. Gil | |
| 0% (0) | Jim Verraros | |
| 0% (0) | EJay Day |
5 voters have answered this question.
Which contestants from SEASON 2 would you nominate?
| 40% (2) | Ruben Studdard | |
|---|---|---|
| 80% (4) | Clay Aiken | |
| 60% (3) | Kimberley Locke | |
| 40% (2) | Josh Gracin | |
| 20% (1) | Trenyce | |
| 0% (0) | Carmen Rasmusen | |
| 20% (1) | Kimberly Caldwell | |
| 0% (0) | Rickey Smith | |
| 0% (0) | Corey Clark | |
| 0% (0) | Julia DeMato | |
| 0% (0) | Charles Grigsby | |
| 0% (0) | Vanessa Olivarez |
5 voters have answered this question.
Season 3?
| 20% (1) | Fantasia Barrino | |
|---|---|---|
| 80% (4) | Diana DeGarmo | |
| 20% (1) | Jasmine Trias | |
| 20% (1) | LaToya London | |
| 0% (0) | George Huff | |
| 0% (0) | John Stevens | |
| 80% (4) | Jennifer Hudson | |
| 20% (1) | Jon Peter Lewis | |
| 0% (0) | Camile Velasco | |
| 20% (1) | Amy Adams | |
| 0% (0) | Matthew Rogers | |
| 0% (0) | Leah LaBelle |
5 voters have answered this question.
Season 4?
| 80% (4) | Carrie Underwood | |
|---|---|---|
| 60% (3) | Bo Bice | |
| 20% (1) | Vonzell Solomon | |
| 20% (1) | Anthony Fedorov | |
| 0% (0) | Scott Savol | |
| 0% (0) | Constantine Maroulis | |
| 20% (1) | Anwar Robinson | |
| 20% (1) | Nadia Turner | |
| 0% (0) | Nikko Smith | |
| 20% (1) | Jessica Sierra | |
| 0% (0) | Mikalah Gordon | |
| 0% (0) | Lindsey Cardinale | |
| 20% (1) | Mario Vazquez |
5 voters have answered this question.
Season 5?
| 14% (1) | Taylor Hicks | |
|---|---|---|
| 71% (5) | Katharine McPhee | |
| 42% (3) | Elliott Yamin | |
| 71% (5) | Chris Daughtry | |
| 14% (1) | Paris Bennett | |
| 42% (3) | Kellie Pickler | |
| 14% (1) | Ace Young | |
| 28% (2) | Bucky Covington | |
| 28% (2) | Mandisa | |
| 14% (1) | Lisa Tucker | |
| 0% (0) | Kevin Covais | |
| 0% (0) | Melissa McGhee |
7 voters have answered this question.
And of course, what about our beloved Season 6?
| 40% (2) | Jordin Sparks | |
|---|---|---|
| 60% (3) | Blake Lewis | |
| 60% (3) | Melinda Doolittle | |
| 40% (2) | LaKisha Jones | |
| 20% (1) | Chris Richardson | |
| 20% (1) | Phil Stacey | |
| 40% (2) | Sanjaya Malakar | |
| 40% (2) | Haley Scarnato | |
| 40% (2) | Gina Glocksen | |
| 0% (0) | Chris Sligh | |
| 20% (1) | Stephanie Edwards | |
| 0% (0) | Brandon Rogers |
5 voters have answered this question.
This poll was created on 2007-05-19 10:48:16
by emarsee2006
