Mister Poll: Harry Potter Catfights: Non-magical!!

So there are four 16-20 year old Hogswarts girls vying for the attention of Harry and his friends: assertive and very pretty Hermione (Emma Watson - 17 y.o., 5'6"); pale, serious Ginny Weasley (Bonnie Wright - 17 y.o., 5'5"); the sultry and solidly build Cho Chang (Katie Leung - 20 y.o., 5'4.5"), and the waif-like Luna Lovegood (Evanna Lynch - 16 y.o., 5'.)

Hermione and Ginny may well be maueuvering for the final affections of Harry. Who would win in a fight without magic:

Hermione would destroy poor Ginny.

Hermione would win a close fight.

Ginny would win a close fight.

Ginny would tear apart a surprised Hermione.

A more immediate threat to Hermione could be Cho Chang, the raven haired scottish girl who gave Harry his first kiss. How eager would Hermione be to claw her way into a catfight with Cho for Harry's affections?

Extreremly eager

Hesitant but willing

Would fight her with trepidation

Would not dare to mix it up wit her.

For her part, how would Cho Chang feel about taking on the slightly taller, but thinner Hermione - especially after the kiss:

No fears about facing up to Hermione

Nervous but willing to fight her

Backs down from Hermione's angry challenge.

So if they DID go at it - who would win?

Hermione would rip Cho apart.

Hermione would just win a close fight.

Cho would conquer a sobbing Hermione after a long battle.

Cho would throw the lighter Hermione down at the beginning and not let her up.

By the way, how would YOU do against the two rivals, if they thought Harry had eyes for you, not them?

I could beat both of them up.

I could take Cho would but lose to Hermione.

I could take Hermione but not Cho.

I wouln't stand a chance against either of them.

Finally, we come come to the new character - sweet, waif-like Luna Lovegood. She's 16, but a mere wisp at 5'0", and she seems harmless enough, but she clearly catches Harry's eye and enchants him out of his grumpiness. This is NOT appreciated by the other three girls, who cluster around Luna threateningly. They tell her she must pick one of them to fight. Trembling, whom does Luna choose to take on?

Hermione

Cho

Ginny

So what do you think Luna's percentage chance of WINNING is against the girl she chose?

And finally, to end on a more personal note, what chances do YOU think you would have against each of the four girls? Girls, answer for yourselves, boys answer for your girlfriend or someone you know. How about a catfight against Hermione?

I would probably get taken pretty easily.

I'd put up a tussle, but she'd take me in the end.

I would slowly overpower her and take her in the end.

I would really beat her up.

How about your wrestling Cho Chang?

I would probably get taken pretty easily.

I'd put up a tussle, but she'd take me in the end.

I would slowly overpower her and take her in the end.

I would really beat her up.

OK, how about a boxing match with stern looking Ginny?

I would probably get taken pretty easily.

I'd put up a tussle, but she'd take me in the end.

I would slowly overpower her and take her in the end.

I would really beat her up.

And finally, how about a slippery little tussle with cute little Luna?

I would probably get taken pretty easily.

I'd put up a tussle, but she'd take me in the end.

I would slowly overpower her and take her in the end.

I would really beat her up.

Thanks for taking the poll! Please feel free to leave suggestions and comments. What did you think of the poll? I appreciate your feedback.

Liked it.

Neutral.

Disliked it.

P.S. - how old are you?

14 or under

15-17

18-20

21 or older

This poll was created on 2007-08-18 18:44:52 by tkat